Ultimately, the quality of the game itself will determine the outcome. If the movement and shooting feel as good as the developers’ pedigree suggests, the negative sentiment from the initial trailer will quickly be forgotten. However, if the game feels generic or fails to offer something unique, even the most clever marketing tactics will not be enough to save it from the crowded live service market. The next forty eight hours will provide the definitive answer to whether this gamble was a masterstroke or a mistake.
This high stakes gamble is designed to turn morbid curiosity into actual player numbers. By inviting top tier streamers and content creators to a private preview event in Los Angeles, the goal is to create a tidal wave of positive impressions just as the game becomes available. Whether this strategy can overcome the initial wave of negativity and skepticism remains to be seen, but it represents a bold departure from traditional video game marketing cycles.
Table of Contents
The power of creator previews and embargoes
A central part of the current plan involved a secret event where prominent first person shooter streamers got their hands on the game. These creators, ranging from Apex Legends specialists to variety streamers, were given the opportunity to play the game on high end hardware and interact with the development team. While an embargo has kept specific details under wraps until now, the social media buzz suggests a level of genuine excitement among those who attended.
The decision to lean heavily on influencers is a calculated move to target specific communities. By convincing the people who drive the most views in the genre, the developers hope to bypass traditional media skepticism. If these creators continue to play Highguard even after their paid engagements end, it will send a strong signal to their audiences that the game is more than just a fleeting project. This organic interest is often the lifeblood of successful live service titles.
Navigating the pitfalls of morbid curiosity
Much of the conversation surrounding the game has been fueled by a collective sense of wonder about why certain industry figures are doubling down on its success. Jeff Keighley has been particularly vocal, even suggesting that he will be waiting for apologies once the public sees the final product. This level of confidence has only added to the curiosity of the average gamer, many of whom still do not fully understand what sets Highguard apart from other titles.
Curiosity can be a powerful driver for day one downloads, especially for a free-to-play game. Unlike previous high profile failures that required a significant upfront purchase, Highguard removes the financial barrier to entry. This means that even the most skeptical players are likely to boot up the game just to see if it lives up to the hype or the criticism. The real challenge will be maintaining those numbers once the initial novelty wears off and players decide if the core mechanics are worth their time.
Historical lessons from games like Evolve
Looking back at the history of multiplayer gaming provides a cautionary tale for any highly anticipated launch. The game Evolve is a perfect example of how positive press and creator hype do not always translate into long term player retention. At its launch in 2014, Evolve was hailed as the next big thing, winning numerous awards and receiving high scores from major publications. It saw a massive spike in players on day one as people flocked to see the new asymmetric combat.
However, the player base for Evolve dropped off a cliff within a single month. The initial excitement was not enough to sustain a community that found the gameplay loop lacking over time. Highguard faces a similar risk if it cannot provide a compelling reason for players to stick around. While the day one concurrent player count on Steam could easily exceed 100,000 based on curiosity alone, the true measure of success will be how many of those players return for a second or third week of play.
The ultimate test of the all press is good press theory
As the embargo lifts and the world finally gets to see Highguard in action, we are witnessing a live experiment in modern marketing. The theory that any attention is good attention is being tested to its limit. If the game turns out to be a massive success, the month of radio silence and the controversial reveal will be seen as a brilliant way to keep the game in the headlines without spending a fortune on traditional ads.
Ultimately, the quality of the game itself will determine the outcome. If the movement and shooting feel as good as the developers’ pedigree suggests, the negative sentiment from the initial trailer will quickly be forgotten. However, if the game feels generic or fails to offer something unique, even the most clever marketing tactics will not be enough to save it from the crowded live service market. The next forty eight hours will provide the definitive answer to whether this gamble was a masterstroke or a mistake.
