Google’s plans for a Web Environment Integrity (WEI) API have sparked significant backlash across the internet. The API, which aims to prevent certain types of fraud by allowing servers to assess the authenticity of devices, has faced criticism from various angles.
Users raised concerns about potential surveillance and discrimination, while others called for regulatory approval and adherence to W3C’s code of Ethics. Even rival browser makers, including Brave and Mozilla, have expressed opposition to the proposed API. Brave’s co-founder and CEO, Brendan Eich, stated that their browser will not support Google’s API, likening it to other “junk” that Google puts into Chromium.
Mozilla developer Brian Grinstead also voiced opposition, suggesting that alternative methods for detecting fraud and invalid traffic should be explored. Vivaldi developer Julien Picalausa criticized Google’s work as “toxic” and “dangerous” but suggested that the EU might investigate the API’s effects if approved.
Despite the backlash, Google has not provided further comments beyond stating that the program has been paused and that they welcome collaboration to find a solution that respects user privacy while maintaining the open nature of the web. Apple has not yet responded to the matter. The situation is still unfolding, and updates are expected in the future.
